Native American or Indian?

Native American Tribes

Today I shared this powerful editorial from the Native Sun News Editorial Board in Rapid City, South Dakota, with a group concerned about Indian affairs. Yes, many Americans and organizations still use the term Indian even though it’s not politically correct.

In recent years there has been increased pressure from the NCAA and others to remove references to Indians from sports and other venues. The very Native Americans these politically correct Pharisees seek to protect sometimes don’t want things changed. You might remember my related discussion of the University of North Dakota’s mascot in my 2011 post The Fighting Sioux.

To date, we still don’t have a new name, and school uniforms have looked sadly blank and generic since the removal of the traditional Native/Indian logo. This sanitizing of modern culture is wiping time-honored Native/Indian references out, and as this wonderfully sharp-tongued opinion piece asks, is it the predominantly white media that’s done that, or Indians themselves?

As I said to the group I was speaking to, as someone with Native American roots among my many European ancestors, I read this and said, “oh yeah!”


Native American vs. American Indian: Political correctness dishonors traditional chiefs of old

Who decided for us that we should be called “Native Americans?”

It was the mainstream media of course. One day a reporter was interviewing an East Coast Indian and the reporter said, “Indian” and the East Coast Indian said, “No, we don’t like to be called Indians because we got that name when Columbus thought he landed in India: We prefer to be called Native Americans.”

“Well,” the reporter replied, “I am of Irish descent but I was born in America so therefore I also am a Native American.” And so when the story was published the Indian people were labeled as Native Americans. The white media had finally pulled one over the indigenous people.

The Lee Enterprise newspapers, and there are several of them in Indian Country, decided to cut this down even further and they told all of their reporters, editors and publishers to just use the word “Native” when referring to Indians, or to be politically correct, Native Americans. So when you read an article that goes, “He was a Native Rapid City guy” that doesn’t mean he was Native, it just means that he was native. In fact everyone who lives in Rapid City is a native.

The activist Russell Means preferred the name American Indian. He would say that just as you have Mexican Americans, African Americans, or Asian Americans, you should have American Indians.

During the activist days of the 1960s and 70s the U. S. Government responded to the activists’ protests by proposing the term “Native American.” And so the anti-government activists decided to accept the name Native American, a name suggested by the United States Government, a government that they despised. Say what?

The other arguable explanation was Columbus’s use of the term “una gest in Dios” or “a people in God” which was reduced to “Indios” for every day usage by the Spaniards and later was further changed to “Indian” as the word moved north. And what’s more we hear that in 1492 Columbus could not have thought he had reached the Indies because at that time there was no Indies, but they instead were called Hindustan.

That sad part of this entire fiasco is that so many of the so-called “elitist Indians” have allowed themselves to be bullied into using the name “Native Americans” and even “Native” by a white media that seems to have set the agenda for what we should be called.

One elderly Lakota man from the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation said recently, “If some Indians want to be called Native Americans or Natives, let them be called that, but I was born an Indian and I shall die an Indian.

So if you travel to any Indian reservation out west you will soon discover that nearly all of the indigenous people refer to themselves as “Indian,” especially the elders who are still fluent in their Indian language. As Chief Oliver Red Cloud said a few years before he died, “I am Lakota and I am Indian.”

As an Indian newspaper we must be very careful that what we call ourselves is not dictated to us by the white media. We have been Indians for a few hundred years and the name carries our history. Crazy Horse, Sitting Bull and Little Wound (Read their quotes) all called themselves “Indian” and they said it with pride. Should we dishonor them by saying they were wrong?

Political correctness be damned: We will use “Indian” if and when we choose. We will not be intimidated by the politically correct bunch or the white media.

The Native Sun News Editorial Board can be reached at

The Native Sun News is based in Rapid City, S.D.

Copyright permission Native Sun News


©2015 H. Hiatt/ All articles/posts on this blog are copyrighted original material that may not be reproduced in part or whole in any electronic or printed medium without prior permission from H. Hiatt/

Seriously, what do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s